7 Best Games of the 7th Generation: Uncharted 2: Among Theives

uncharted-2-headerAs the current console generation went on, games increasingly tried to be like interactive movies. The goal seemed to be to recreate the Hollywood experience but with you playing the starring role using a controller. While one could argue that Heavy Rain may have gotten the closest, no game captured the fun of the summer blockbuster while releasing a solid game quite like Naughty Dog.

Since today marks both the launch of the PlayStation 4 and our 7 For 7 series, I thought that it was only appropriate to kick off with the epic PlayStation 3 exclusive Uncharted 2: Among Thieves.

Naughty Dog is a developer that you can say has aged with its audience. They were among the early foreign developers on the PlayStation thanks to the advice of then Universal Interactive Studios boss Mark Cerny (who is the lead architect of the PlayStation 4). They started on the PlayStation with the critically acclaimed and E rated Crash Bandicoot series. Their PlayStation 2 years were spent on the new Jak and Daxter series that was also well received by critics and saw Naughty Dog move up to a Teen rating. The games were so popular that they became flagship franchises and the characters became mascots for the PlayStation.

uncharted-2-screenshot-01For the PlayStation 3, Naughty Dog created the M-rated Uncharted franchise. The series starred Nathan Drake, a treasure hunter who is part Indiana Jones and part Lara Croft. Tagging along were Elena Fisher, a reporter and Drake’s love interest, and Victor “Goddamn” Sullivan, Drake’s cigar smoking mentor.

The first game, Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune, was praised for just about everything that it did. Critics loved the visuals, the score and the dialogue. Most of all, the characters and presentation of the game drew scads of acclaim with numerous critics and fans drawing comparisons between Uncharted and summer blockbuster movies, including the Indiana Jones series. With the release of Uncharted, Naughty Dog once again created a flagship franchise for Sony.

uncharted-2-screenshot-02-train-crashUncharted 2 certainly didn’t wait before kicking things off with a trademark set piece. Drake waking up on a derailed train and climbing his way up it to safety was the trademark set piece of the game. Things never really let up from there with big gun battles and set pieces scattered throughout the game.

The gameplay itself saw a marked improvement from Drake’s Fortune as enemy variety increased and enemy AI was improved. That was balanced with improvements in moving into, between and out of cover. The scattered addition of mini-bosses also helped to improve the combat experience in UC2.

I could talk about the story but it’s largely inconsequential. The dialogue and the performances by the actors were just spectacular. While everyone remembers the graphics and the action movie-esque explosions, it’s really the characters that are the heart of the game. I’m not sure that any “serious” video game voice actor could have brought Nathan Drake to like in the same tounge-in-cheek way Nolan North does. Richard McGonagle’s voice absolutely makes Victor Sullivan the memorable character he is. And Emily Rose… Okay, I’m not sure that I could definitively say that no one else could do Elena as well as Emily but she still does an excellent job.If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.

From a visual standpoint, Naughty Dog set the bar for console gaming with Uncharted 2. While the first Uncharted was a good-looking game, especially for a game that was released one year into the console’s life, it was absolutely blown out of the water by Uncharted 2. The textures were much more detailed and crisp than Uncharted. The character models were improved and looked fantastic. And the set pieces were bigger and more spectacular, including the aforementioned train sequence.

I would be remiss if I didn’t note some of the spectacular environments that were featured. Of particular note, the icy levels of Tibet, especially the ice cavern segment with Drake and Tenzin, were just stunning and I’m not sure anything on console has matched them (apart from maybe Journey). The fact  Overall, Naughty Dog turned the visuals up to 11.

uncharted-vs-uncharted-2-comparisonThis was because, as a PlayStation exclusive developer, Naughty Dog was dedicated to maximizing the hardware of the PS3, something that multiplatform devs didn’t always have the time or know-how to do. For Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune, Naughty Dog was able to use around 30% of the power the PS3’s cell processor was capable of. Naughty Dog says that for Uncharted 2, they were able to use over 90% of the power on hand which made for a massive graphical upgrade over the previous game.

While the first Uncharted was critically acclaimed, it’s 89.67% GameRankings aggregated score was dwarfed by the 96.38% for Uncharted 2. In addition to the praise that Uncharted 2 was a game of the year favourite in 2009, many critics considered it one of the greatest games ever made at the time of release. Critics would often refer to Among Thieves as closer to a movie experience than any other game previously thanks to the story, the stunning visuals and crisp gameplay.

The long and short of it is that Uncharted 2: Among Thieves may not just be one of the best games of the current generation of video game consoles but one of the most influential games of all-time.

uncharted-2-screenshot-04Sure, the Uncharted series was influenced by the likes of Indiana  Jones and Tomb Raider but it also helped set the direction of games for the rest of this generation. Sure, cover-based third-person shooters as we currently know them were really introduced by the Xbox 360 exclusive Gears of War franchise but the genre was perfected by Uncharted.

That doesn’t include the platforming elements of the Uncharted series. Among Thieves improved on the already solid platforming in Drake’s Fortune. If you’ve played a game with a climbing platforming section, chances are that the gameplay will be almost identical to what you’d see in Uncharted with easily visible ledges to grab and reaching animation as you aim Drake for the next jump.

uncharted-2-screenshot-03Most importantly, Uncharted 2 has arguably brought us the closest that gaming has ever been to being a movie that you can play. As video games get better at visuals and story and acting, the comparisons between movies and gaming increase. The general consensus is that the Uncharted franchise, and especially Uncharted 2, set the bar against which all other games were judged as interactive movies.

The long and short of it is that Uncharted 2: Among Thieves is simply the best game on the PlayStation 3.

For more from et geekera, follow us on FacebookTwitterGoogle+Tumblr and RSS.


About Steve Murray

Steve is the founder and editor of The Lowdown Blog and et geekera. On The Lowdown Blog, he often writes about motorsports, hockey, politics and pop culture. Over on et geekera, Steve writes about geek interests and lifestyle. Steve is on Twitter at @TheSteveMurray.

Posted on November 15, 2013, in Games, Long Read and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 3 Comments.

  1. bold words, while I can’t find the best game on PS3, I do agree with everything else. Uncharted is awesome! Naughty Dog to me is the trendsetter and will continue to be this into next-gen which I guess is now current-gen with the next Uncharted game. Awesome article Steve. Are you an Uncharted fan?


    • Thanks very much. Glad you liked it.

      I am an Uncharted fan. (That’s not how the rest of the list goes but it worked out here.) I think it’s more to do with the characters than the gameplay or visuals. Not saying those aren’t good but I’m more interested in the narrative in games than anything and it’s Uncharted’s well-written and well-acted characters that get me. Especially Sully.

      I just found Uncharted 2 to be the most fun of the bunch. Sure, UC3 and The Last of Us were very good games and I’m not implying they weren’t fun but for me, UC2 just did it absolutely right.

      And I’m definitely intrigued with what Naughty Dog has in store for the next Uncharted. I find that teaser interesting. I’m a little worried about the darker turn the teaser threatens to take the series. However, that Latin at the end of the video makes me think that people are going in the wrong direction by speculating pirates. But I think I may leave elaboration in case I do a PS4 launch write-up for Monday.


  2. I agree with you about Uncharted 2 being the best. The kind of person I am, Uncharted 2 was like living my child hood fantasy’s, exploring undiscovered locations, action movie set pieces that rival the days of The Rock and Con Air.

    I also agree completely that the characters and narrative are the main substance. I love Nolan North and no one can top him and Sully is just…hilarious. I love the banter between them, their relationship is solid and you can totally see it and feel it when they talk to each other, you just sense this history.

    I read a while back that during the “making of The Last of US” documentary, behind one of the devs who was being interviewed, on the monitor behind him, you could see a characters in pirate clothes, with that said I have no idea what the latin word means.

    I don’t think it will necessarily take a dark approach because I don’t think that’s what Uncharted is but maybe a more serious approach is the cards, something that has real consequences for Drake and the gang.

    I also hope to see Chloe again, she had spunk.

    There were so many funny lines in Uncharted 2:

    “Elena Fisher, last years model”

    Harry Flynn: Well, look at you. Victor ‘goddamn’ Sullivan.

    [to Nate]

    Harry Flynn: You still dragging this tired old sack of shit around?

    [Nate moves toward Flynn but is halted by Sully]

    Victor Sullivan: Easy, Nate

    Harry Flynn: That’s pretty ballsy for a guy who’s spent the last three months behind bars.

    Nathan Drake: Better than pissing away three months in the jungle without a clue.

    Harry Flynn: Found the ships though, didn’t I?

    Nathan Drake: You couldn’t find your ass with both hands.


    Chloe Frazer: [Chloe covers her nose after entering filthy jail cell] Dear God!

    Nathan Drake: [sarcastically] Oh no, its not that bad. Look, I have my own bucket!’


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: